Follow us on Twitter      |   Join us on    

Central Government, Information Security

Are civil servants cut out for social media?

Most senior civil servants are Baby Boomers or Generation Xers, born at a time without the internet. But does this mean that web communities are too ‘young’ for top officials to operate in effectively? In interviews with FutureGov, government officials from Australia, Malaysia and the UK argue that although civil servants may not feel comfortable using social media to reach young citizens, the rewards are worth the risks.

Photos

View photos

The average age of a specialist IT developer in the government of South Australia is 58. The state’s CIO, Andrew Mills, says that while the medium does not come naturally to many in the civil service, social media has become “a fact of life” for governments that want to reach out to young citizens. “If you want to talk to people, you need to go to the place where they’re talking,” he said.”

Craig Thomler is the Online Communications Director for the Government of Australia’s Department of Health and Ageing. “Young people are more casual in their use of social media, and are more adept at creating their own spaces online,” he told FutureGov. “For older generations, social media can be like going to another country.”

Datuk Arpah binti Abdul Razak, Director General of Local Government in Malaysia, observes that her younger officers have taken “like ducks to water” to social media. “They are very comfortable with it, and have a natural inclination to use it. The older generation of civil servants still prefer the conventional methods of networking; meetings, business lunches, and so on.”

The generation gap could be less a factor than a reluctance to take risks. Arpah noted: “Some government departments bar their people from using social media altogether. Partly, I think, due to the risk-averse nature of the civil service.” However, she added, if the technology is used properly, and guidelines are adhered to, the risk that goes with using social media can be minimised.”

Glyn Evans, the Director of Business Change at Birmingham City Council in the UK says that age has little to do whether or not a civil servant gets social media. “It depends on whether you are an active participant generally. I’m not, and don’t generally use social media for work purposes. But others do. Is there an age-related aspect to this?”

There is an expectation by the social media community of instantaneous responses and, in general, civil servants are more deliberative, he added. “Also, external communication has traditionally been mediated through communications professionals whereas social media engagement is direct and potentially puts the civil servant personally ‘in the firing line’. I’ve experienced this directly, and it’s not particularly comfortable.”

British civil servants are being encouraged to get more involved online. The greater use of digital technologies was a key part of Prime Minister Gordon Brown’s recent speech, and the Conservative opposition has been making similar noises. With a General Election looming, use of social media by civil servants is “likely to increase significantly,” says Evans.

But Evans notes that it would be wrong to force individual civil servants to use social media if they are reluctant to do so. ”We should ensure that civil servants should be aware of both the opportunities and challenges that using social media present.” Recently published guidelines for tweeting or Facebooking civil servants, are “practical and sensible”, says Evans.

Rate this article

4 Comments

On 8 April 2010 TD500 wrote:

Interesting blog, Robin. The generation which now runs governments across the West is not Generation X, nor the Baby Boomers, but instead is the heretofore lost generation in-between: Generation Jones. As many prominent observers have noted, Obama is part of GenJones, and he is surrounded by other GenJonesers, including Rahm Emanuel, David Axelrod, Valerie Jarrett, Ben Bernanke, Larry Summers, Tim Geithner,Stanley McChrystal, Janet Napolitano, Susan Rice, etc. Countries across the West are now led by GenJonesers, including France’s Sarkozy, Germnay’s Merkel, Canada’s Harper, Australia’s Rudd, etc. In fact, more than two thirds of current EU and NATO leaders are members of Generation Jones. Here is an article titled: “Generation Jones and the New Era of Global Leadership”: http://www.r…>

Google Generation Jones, and you’ll see it’s gotten lots of media attention, and many top commentators from many top publications and networks (Washington Post, Time magazine, NBC, Newsweek, ABC, etc.) now specifically use this term. In fact, the Associated Press' annual Trend Report chose the Rise of Generation Jones as the #1 trend of 2009.

It is important to distinguish between the post-WWII demographic boom in births vs. the cultural generations born during that era. Generations are a function of the common formative experiences of its members, not the fertility rates of its parents. And most analysts now see generations as getting shorter (usually 10-15 years now), partly because of the acceleration of culture. Many experts now believe it breaks down more or less this way:

DEMOGRAPHIC boom in babies: 1946-1964
Baby Boom GENERATION: 1942-1953
Generation Jones: 1954-1965
Generation X: 1966-1978

Here are a couple of other GenJones links:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Ta_Du5K0jk

http://generationjones.com/2009latest.html


On 9 April 2010 Kerry Webb wrote:

The average age of a civil servant in the government of South Australia is 58.”

Really? They're going to be in a lot of trouble in a couple of years.


On 23 April 2010 Robin Hicks wrote:

Kerry, thanks for alerting me to an inaccuracy.

The average age of a South Australian civil servant is obviously not 58! The reference was to a small group of specialist developers in the South Australian government. I have now amended the story to reflect this.

Thanks again,
Robin


On 29 April 2010 Madonna Townsley wrote:

Its a great time for democracy. While the civil servants might be more directly in the firing line because of the immediacy of social media the messages may be less mediated by political spin and will be necessity need to be more responsive.


Add your comment


Most highly rated

Better learning with web 2.0 and virtual worlds

In a visit to Ngee Ann Secondary School yesterday (22 July), FutureGov found students deeply ...

Artificial Intelligence Tools to be Used in Singapore Schools

The Infocomm Development Authority and Ministry of Education of Singapore have initiated plans to introduce ...

Students take a green stance with social media

Ngee Ann Secondary School’s students are on a bid to “change the world” with ...